Comparisons
The differences that cause the most doubt before making a claim, explained plainly.
| Criterion | Normal wear | Defect or premature failure |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship with use | Consistent with mileage, age and maintenance | Appears earlier than that use would explain |
| Part affected | Consumables: brake pads, tyres, clutch | Parts designed to last much longer |
| What must be shown | The maintenance schedule and compliance with it | The technical cause and, if claiming against the seller, that it already existed |
| Workshop invoice or report | Expert report | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is for | States what was done or found | Answers a specific technical question |
| Who signs it | Whoever carried out the repair | An expert who undertakes to act objectively (art. 335.2 Civil Procedure Act) |
| Can it be checked? | It depends on what it includes | Every conclusion refers to its data |
| At trial | A document from the party | Expert evidence the expert can confirm and defend |
| On-call time (tiempo de presencia) | Actual work | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Available to the company without performing actual work (RD 1561/1995, art. 8.1) | Driving, ancillary work and loading or unloading |
| Loading or unloading waits | The first two hours of each wait (art. 10.4.c) | From the third hour onwards, unless a foreseeable duration is set by collective agreement |
| Limit | Twenty hours a week on average over a month (art. 8.3) | Maximum working hours, with a total daily cap of twelve hours (art. 8.2) |
| Party-appointed expert | Court-appointed expert | |
|---|---|---|
| When filed | With the claim or the defence (art. 336.1 Civil Procedure Act) | Requested in the initial pleadings (art. 339.2) |
| Who chooses | The commissioning party | The court |
| How to challenge | Objection known as tacha (art. 343.1) | Recusal (art. 343.1) |
These tables are a guide and do not replace a study of your case. The collective agreement and the specific facts may change the answer.
Tell me about your case Book a call