Automotive guide
They are three different things with different deadlines. Knowing which one applies to you comes first, because it decides who you claim against and until when.
| Route | When it applies | Deadline |
|---|---|---|
| Hidden defects | Buying from a private seller, under the Civil Code. | Six months from delivery (art. 1490 of the Civil Code). |
| Statutory guarantee of conformity | Buying from a trader when you are a consumer. | Three years. For used goods it may be shortened, never below one year (art. 120.1). |
| Commercial warranty | The one the seller or manufacturer offers voluntarily, often called a «mechanical warranty». | Whatever its document says. It does not replace the statutory one (art. 127). |
If you bought from a dealership or a used-car business, the statutory guarantee of conformity exists even if nobody mentions it. The seller is liable for any lack of conformity that already existed when the vehicle was handed over and that appears within the following three years. For a used vehicle you may agree a shorter period, but never less than one year (art. 120.1 of the consolidated Consumer Protection Act).
What helps you most is the presumption in art. 121.1: anything that fails in the first two years is presumed to have been there at delivery, unless the seller proves otherwise. For used goods that presumption may be agreed shorter, but not below the agreed guarantee period. The claim becomes time-barred five years after the lack of conformity appears (art. 124).
Repair or replacement costs you nothing: transport, labour and parts are on the seller (art. 118.4).
Many sellers hand over a mechanical warranty contract, sometimes backed by an insurer, with a list of covered parts and a cap on the amount. That is a commercial warranty. It binds whoever gives it on the terms of its document and its advertising (art. 127.1). And that document must state expressly that it does not affect your rights under the statutory guarantee (art. 127.3.a).
In other words: a part missing from the mechanical warranty list does not let the seller off. If the defect was already there, the statutory guarantee still applies.
If you bought from a private seller there is no statutory guarantee of conformity. What remains is the Civil Code remedy for hidden defects: defects that already existed, could not be seen and are serious (art. 1484), within six months of delivery (art. 1490). It is short and forgives no oversight.
They may be right about their commercial warranty and wrong about the statutory guarantee. They are different things. What has to be established is whether the defect existed when the vehicle was handed over to you. That is a technical question.
No. Wear that is normal for the vehicle's age and mileage is not a lack of conformity. That is why the expert report separates normal wear from what was already wrong.
Hidden vehicle defects expert witness →
Tell me about your case Book a call