Automotive guide
You sold a car, a van or a truck and now the buyer says it had a hidden defect. Before you reply, it helps to know what the buyer has to prove and what you can prove.
If you sold as a private individual, the Spanish Civil Code applies. A hidden-defects claim lapses six months after delivery of the vehicle (art. 1490). If the claim arrives later, that route is closed. The buyer may still try others, such as fraud, if they argue you knowingly concealed something.
If you sold as a trader (a dealership, a used-car business or a workshop) to a consumer, the framework is different: the statutory guarantee of conformity in the consolidated Consumer Protection Act. It lasts three years from delivery, which for a used vehicle may be shortened by agreement but never below one year (art. 120.1). Anything that fails in the first two years is presumed to have been there already and it is up to you to prove otherwise (art. 121.1).
Article 1484 of the Civil Code does not cover every fault. The defect has to meet all of these:
Even if you did not know about the defect you are still liable, unless the contract said otherwise (art. 1485). If you knew and did not say so, a buyer who unwinds the sale can also claim damages from you (art. 1486).
Almost all these claims turn on one technical point: whether the fault was there before or appeared afterwards, through use, lack of maintenance or a repair by the new owner. An opinion does not settle that. The part, the history and the mileage do.
It can help, but not always. Article 1485 of the Civil Code allows the parties to agree that you are not liable for hidden defects you were unaware of. If you knew about the defect, the clause does not cover you. And if you sold as a trader to a consumer, the statutory guarantee of conformity cannot go below the legal minimums.
A workshop report usually says what is broken and what it costs to fix. It rarely explains since when it has been broken, which is exactly what is in dispute. Analysing that report and answering it with an expert report of your own is a common assignment.
It depends on the vehicle and on what has to be proved. The first study of your documents costs you nothing and then you receive a fixed quote in writing.
Hidden vehicle defects expert witness →
Tell me about your case Book a call